Free vs. Paid Directory Submissions: How Much Time Can $20 Save? I Ran an A/B Test
Half of the directories are free, the other half are paid. The free ones require you to find, submit, and track them yourself. The paid ones are one‑click. Which is more cost‑effective? I tried both and let the data speak.
📅 September 27 2026 · ⏱️ ~6 min read · 📂 SEO · Cost Analysis · Real‑world Test
I’m often asked: “Do I have to spend money on directory submissions? Is the free option enough?”
Answer: The free option does work, but it costs you time.
To see whether “time for money” is worth it, I ran a simple A/B test. Same website, two methods, compare the results.
Test Design
Test subject: A friend’s SaaS product, just launched 2 months ago, DR 9.
Group A (Free): I manually found directories, submitted, and tracked them.
Group B (Paid): Used BackLinkSubmit’s Growth plan ($44.9 for 50 platforms).
Both groups started at the same time and were tracked for 30 days.
Fairness note: I tried to keep the quality of the directories submitted by both groups comparable—all DR 30+. For Group A I filtered for the same quality as Group B.
Group A: Free Route
What I did:
| Step | Time Spent | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Gather directory list | 2 h | Google search + competitor backlink analysis |
| Filter DR 30+ | 1 h | Checked each with Ahrefs free version |
| Verify directory activity | 1 h | Used site: search to confirm they’re still being crawled |
| Prepare 4 description variants | 1.5 h | Write unique descriptions to avoid duplication |
| Submit individually (50) | 6 h | 8‑10 per day, over 6 days |
| Track indexing status | 1 h | First check after 7 days |
| Resubmit unindexed entries | 0.5 h | Change description and resubmit |
| Total | 13 h |
Results after 30 days:
| Metric | Data |
|---|---|
| Submissions | 50 |
| Indexed | 36 |
| Indexing rate | 72 % |
| DR change | 9 → 14 (+5) |
| My time cost | 13 h |
Group B: Paid Route
What I did:
| Step | Time Spent | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Enter product URL | 2 min | BackLinkSubmit auto‑matches |
| Review submission list | 10 min | Check AI‑recommended directories for reasonableness |
| Pay | 2 min | $44.9 one‑time |
| Wait | 0 min | Their manual team handles the submissions |
| Check dashboard | 10 min | See progress and indexing status |
| Total | 24 min |
Results after 30 days:
| Metric | Data |
|---|---|
| Submissions | 50 |
| Indexed | 41 |
| Indexing rate | 82 % |
| DR change | 9 → 15 (+6) |
| My time cost | 24 min |
| Money cost | $44.9 |
Comparison
| Group A (Free) | Group B (Paid) | Difference | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Submissions | 50 | 50 | Same |
| Indexed | 36 | 41 | +5 for B |
| Indexing rate | 72 % | 82 % | +10 % for B |
| DR change | +5 | +6 | Slightly higher for B |
| Time invested | 13 h | 24 min | A is 32× longer |
| Money invested | $0 | $44.9 | A saves $44.9 |
Group B’s indexing rate is 10 % higher than Group A’s. This may be because BackLinkSubmit’s AI matching is more precise than my manual filtering, or because their human submissions are higher quality (each directory gets a custom description).
How Much Is Time Worth?
Group A cost me 13 h and saved $44.9.
Calculation: $44.9 ÷ 13 h = $3.45 per hour.
If your time is worth more than $3.45 / hour—paying is the better deal.
Who values their time above $3.45 / hour?
Basically everyone.
- Independent developers: $50‑$100 / hour (based on income or opportunity cost)
- SaaS founders: $100‑$200 / hour
- Freelancers: $30‑$80 / hour
- Students: $10‑$20 / hour (but students usually need money more than time)
Conclusion: If your time is worth more than $3.45 / hour (almost all entrepreneurs), paying is more economical.
But this conclusion assumes you trust the quality of the paid service.
When to Choose the Free Route
Paid isn’t always better. The free route makes sense in these cases:
1. Your time isn’t valuable right now
If you’re a student, recent graduate, or a founder not yet earning, your opportunity cost is low. Spending 13 h to save $44.9 is reasonable.
2. You want to learn SEO
Doing the directory submissions yourself teaches you how to filter directories, write descriptions, and track indexing—knowledge you’ll reuse later.
3. You only need 10‑15 core directories
If you only target 10‑15 high‑DR (50+) directories, manual work takes 3‑4 h. Paying for that isn’t cost‑effective.
4. You don’t trust paid services
If you’re unsure about a paid service’s quality, try a small batch yourself first. If it works, then consider supplementing with a paid service.
When to Choose the Paid Route
1. Your time is valuable
Developers, SaaS founders, freelancers—your time should be spent coding, building products, or serving clients, not on 13 h of directory submissions.
2. You need to submit 30+ directories
Submitting 10 directories manually is quick, but 30‑50 becomes a slog. Paid services scale better.
3. You want a higher indexing rate
My data shows a 10 % boost with the paid service, likely due to better AI matching, higher‑quality human submissions, or a superior directory list.
4. You want to avoid pitfalls
Manual work can lead to spammy directories, duplicate descriptions, or bulk‑submission spam flags. Paid services help you sidestep those issues.
A Third Option: Hybrid Approach
The smartest strategy is often a hybrid:
First batch (10‑15): Do it manually. Pick the most important DR 50+ directories and submit yourself. You learn the process and ensure quality.
Second batch (20‑30): Hand it over to a paid service. Let AI matching + human submission handle the less familiar directories.
Benefits:
- You learn the submission process (knowledge)
- You save ~80 % of the time (efficiency)
- You get a higher indexing rate (quality)
- Total cost remains $44.9 (economy)
Summary
| Option | Time | Cost | Indexing Rate | Who It Fits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| All free | 13 h | $0 | 72 % | Plenty of time, tight budget |
| All paid | 24 min | $44.9 | 82 % | Time‑scarce, budget OK |
| Hybrid | 4 h + 24 min | $44.9 | ~78 % | Most balanced choice |
My personal recommendation: the hybrid route. Do 10‑15 core directories yourself (learn), then let the paid service handle the rest (save time).
Final Thought
$44.9 buys you back 13 hours.
In those 13 hours you could write two in‑depth articles, perform a competitor analysis, or pitch five industry bloggers. The SEO payoff from those activities far exceeds 13 hours of directory submissions.
Spend money to buy time, and spend that time where the return is higher.
That’s the smartest resource allocation for independent developers and small teams in 2026.
BackLinkSubmit Team — starting at $19.9 for 20 curated platforms. AI matching + human submission + indexing tracking. See plans →
Share Article
